I have a JB in the bridge of my tele and a Pearly Gates in the bridge of my strat. The JB has a fuller sound and can get very heavy, does classic rock to metal. The Pearly Gates has a great blues & classic rock crunch, I wouldn't really call it a metal PU....the mids sound a little scooped, the sound is not as full as a JB. They sound different but both are great. The Classic 5 is also a great PU, sort of in between a JB & Pearly Gates. My 2 cents......YMMV.