Suhr,
I see that you play "Christian Alternative". Does this include worship music? Do you guys use a click track/loop? If so, please note that to get the delay sounds used on a lot of today's christian recordings, your delay has to be perfectly timed to the click. Tap tempo is not reliable for this function (in my opinion), and I can sympathize that there is literally no time in between songs to bend over and fumble around with a stomp box. You NEED presets, and you need to be able to access them quickly and reliably. I have had SEVERAL delay units, and I came to the eventual conclusion that the TimeFactor is the absolute best for our application, and should be the default delay pedal for any praise musician. Here is why:
1) 100 banks of two programmable presets each
2) Easily accessible channels with a large LED screen, easy to read in the dark.
3) VERY transparent, does not color tone unless you want it to.
4) Highly adjustable, can make a very wide variety of sounds.
5) A whole bunch of technical reasons that make it just sound better (For one, it actually has two processors, to make two delays simultaneously, etc)
This pedal will take hours to master, though. I recommend an external switch for it. Mine is red and sparkly!
If price is an issue, you could always get a DD-20 or TimeBender.... but you will be limited to 5 presets with each, and honestly they do not sound as good.
I hope this helps!
-JUS-