Also,those caps appear to be stock,probably a good idea to change them too.If they are still stock I assume the amp is from '83 or '84.I know there are a lot of different opinions on the life of caps but many techs will agree that 10 years is about it,personally,I like to change them after 6 to 8 years even if they seem to be good.I have always noticed an improvement tonewise with fresh caps.When caps get that old they tend to fail suddenly when they do go south,which can cause other problems.Just my 2 cents.
As for the difference in tone with the same tubes the power tubes probably have a different bias in each amp,another good reason to put the 50k cermet pot in there.As long as you now know which resistor to change,why not do both amps,I havent seen the price on those pots as I got 25 of them years ago for about $3.00 but I am sure they cant be more than a buck or 2 each.