I agree with you on a large part Russ. I'm not trying to sell anything. Before I bought my 3ch I called mesa to ask why do so many people prefer the 2ch or hype it up. I received that same answer "there is nothing one does the other can not." I was content on that and went ahead with the purchase. At first I was blown away by the sound because I had never heard such an amp. But after a while you begin to develop an ear for intricacies. When I got my 2ch and hit about 3 chords with flat settings, it was all so clear all of a sudden. that "blanket" was lifted. I've done a lot of messing with the 3ch since then and I can come close, but the 2ch still beats it, even if not by much, every time. I still love my 3ch because of its clean, pushed, raw, and ability to have 3ch and a solo boost. But in tone, I still like the older one. I believe the best thing you can do to achieve some of the clarity on the 3ch is change the tubes and upgrade your guitar, unless you got a good one already. Unless you're not a tone freak or have OCD like I do, the model you have doesn't matter. They sound largely the same and your crowd certainly won't notice. *I dont mean to offend anyone! I just want to share my experiences.*