Elixir said:
Yes, voicing. I feel a lot of people when giving suggestions to others seem to leave this most important aspect out. It's just voiced completely different and it may or may not be for you. I love love love the Mark tones but it just wasn't for me.
Yeah lots of people tend to overlook an amps voicing or character. For instance the classic recto vs mark... both lines have great qualities, both do the high gain thing, both (at least now) have great cleans, both can do the mid gain thing, both have some nice bells and whistles. The main difference is in the overall voicing of the amp... the Mark has its voice, the Recto has its voice. If they sounded too similar then why have two different lines?
So getting back on topic, JC if your still not totally bought on a particular amp I would go out there and play as many as you can find. I wouldnt limit yourself to Mesa either because there are some great, quality amps out there (VHT, Bogner, Splawn, ENGL, etc.) which might be the amp for you. I'm not by any means trying to disuade you from the Roadster, hell if anything I could go all day about how much i love mine, but at the end of the day when making a $2000+ investment you should purchase with the confidence that this is THE amp (or at least THE amp for now).
Definitely check out the Mark IV or V, the Stiletto, and I would even say check out a DC-10 or DC-5 if you can find one used. Those amps have great cleans and a killer lead channel, and are pretty affordible on the used market. As far as non-Mesa amps I love the VHT Sig:X, its not for everyone because the VHTs have their own voicings but I love that type tone. Also the Splawn Nitro is killer too... very much a super up Marshall, but in my eyes everything a Marshall should be, quite like the Stiletto. Both the Nitro and Sig:X are right in the same price range as the Roadster, Mark V and Stiletto.