xcpointx said:
Interesting.
I wish I could hear the difference tubes make. I've been using tube amps (starting with a 70's Marshall JML MKII Super Bass) since 98 and gone through my fair share of changes.
In preamp tubes I cant even hear a difference between JJ's and EH's. One is supposed to quite bright, and the other dark???!!
My amp tech tells me the audio signal doesnt actually go through these tubes, so they dont actually have as much affect as they are purported to be?
The only thing Ive once noticed is using a lower gain tube for the phase inverter to drop the output from the preamp section of the Marshall (at that time I was aiming for crystal clean sounds).
You have obviously been playing for ages too. Ive got 2 Raytheons lying around. What will they do for me that the Mesa tubes in my TA wont? I must also try the EH and JJ's in there.
You've got the Raytheons with black plates and halo-getter rings? I use one in the V1 position (closest to the guitar input jack). This tube position is only in use in Lead 1 modes, when the circuit goes V2(1st input)->V1(2nd gain stage). I use a Mullard CV4024 in V2, and I find the combo with the Ratheon to be heavenly.
You could also try the Raytheon in the V2 position. This makes it available for all modes, but you'd especially notice a change in the clean/rhythm modes.
Here's the rub: preamp tube changes are less pronounced when you're maxing out the gain in the circuit. So if you're not using cleans or settings on the verge of breakup, then the impact is reduced.
Also, if you're not noticing changes, don't sweat it. If all tubes seem equal to you, then save your money by buying the less-expensive ones. Do note, however, that the most impact will come from changing the first input valve (closest to input jack), and then the second gain-stage valve. Changes to the phase-inverter (PI) valve (closest to the power tubes in a class AB combo amp [there is none in a preamp]) are more subtle than V1 and V2 changes, but can still have an impact on dynamic sensitivity and power-tube response.
What I've noticed, besides tonal shadings, in a NOS optimized amp is:
- more open, airy, and dynamically responsive (less compressed) feel
- better ability to clean up
- highly articulate detail throughout the frequency ranges
- extended frequency response: higher and sweeter highs, lower and tighter lows
- longer service life (yes, I can say this now, since it has been a few years)
- custom tones to suit one's taste, and the ability to change this at will (for, say, a recording with a different guitar)
- T