fjk1138 said:
Update: The tech could not reproduce the problem, and the store supposedly tried it for 2 hours and also could not get it to fail. Neither tried replacing any preamp tubes since they heard no problems. Am I losing it, or is there some other factor at work here that would cause it fail at home and not the repair shop? I've exhausted every possibility as far as I can tell.
Also....Called Mesa and they suggested maybe V5, then V4, but I cannot pick it up until Saturday, so I cannot try this now. Will post results asap.
You aren't losing it man. I am sure that it is a preamp tube issue. I had a similar issue with my Roadster a long time ago that made me similarly insane. My problem was that I never owned a Mesa before and never had tube issues with my Fender amps (which have less tubes). Anyways, the techs should've detected something if anything else was causing the problems.
With tubes, as the amp heats up, if a tube has a weak connection within, the heat can cause things to separate and cause any number of audible issues. The key here is to find the bad tube. If you told Mesa the issues you were hearing, switch both V5 and V4 as directed and move on and play confidently. You could switch out each tube individually and wait, or switch out both. Keep the tubes in two separate bags and mark the bags by which V-slot the tubes originated from. If the issues persist, call back Mesa and ask them for some more troubleshooting tips. Intermittent issues are the most difficult to solve, but you've done the hard part. It may seem troubling that Mesa can't direct you exactly as to which tube to switch out, but this is the problem with intermittent tube issues. Chances are that you have a faulty tube. Like I stated before, your best bet would be to change out V4 AND V5, and if you have further issues, try other preamp slots. More or so likely, if issues persist, if wasn't one of the V4 or V5 tubes.
I would buy three preamp tubes -- two for V4 and V5, and one just in case. Play away and have fun. If the problem comes back, try the other slots. Be patient and enjoy your amp and stop thinking there is something more wrong with it that is going unnoticed.
Believe me, I've had maddening issues too. When I bought my Roadster (new), I had a weird reverb tank issue that was bewildering a Mesa tech. After a couple of appointments we found out the hard way that there was a weak wire connected to the reverb tank. Everytime the tech would reset connecting the reverb tank back to the amp, things would seem to be solved. Anyways, the issue was solved and believe me, that was a freak issue at best. Chances are good that you have a preamp tube that is going wacky and needs to be switched out. No biggie really.
Good luck!