Hey there,
Funny I just came across this thread as I have been experiencing what seems to be a similar issue. I just got a JP-2C off of Reverb a couple of weeks ago. I’ve only played it a few times but last night at practice I was thinking to myself that it seemed to lack saturation on Channel 2. I have the gain at 3:00 and I’m using the classic V shape EQ. I have Shred mode off and I believe I have Presence pulled. It feels like it’s choking somewhat, especially on individual notes. If I play a power chord, it sounds full and crunchy and tight with a lot of power but those individual notes, especially if palm muted seem like they have a lot of initial attack but then just choke off.
I’ve only just changed the power tubes and haven’t touched the preamp tubes but perhaps I need to look into that. It’s one of the earlier versions for sure which still has the FX Loop issue that Mesa acknowledged and is fixing. I’m going to have the fix applied but was wondering if perhaps I have another issue like you had?
What was the specifics of your issue, a relay? Did you just send it in to Mesa and have them do a once over on it to verify if it was operating properly or not and that’s how they found the problem?
Thanks!