Russ said:
I have also never heard of a pickup sounding compressed.... How would you guys rate the Evolution or the Fred?
I refer to any pickup where the output kills your dynamics as compressed. If I can't pick lightly and have it sound quiet, or hear separate notes within a chord the pickup is too compressed IMO.
I've never tried either of the above two pickups.
That said, I should quantify my above post by saying that high output pickups are fine for low/mid gain amplifiers that need the extra kick to spur the preamp on......but for high gain amps of any sort (unless they have a specific sound you can't get in a lower output pickup) I find them pointless. I find it sounds better to use a low output pickup with the amps gain turned up than it does to use a high output pickup with the amps gain turned down.
For instance, one of the reasons I hate the JB is because it sounds like I always have an OD turned on. Too compressed, big mid spike, and a huge lack of dynamics. Sounds nice for leads, but gives a crappy rhythm tone (IMO).
And yes, I ride the volume knobs. I typically setup my rhythm tone for 7, and crank them up to 9 or 10 for leads.
That said, everything I said above is subjective. When it comes to something like tone, use whatever sounds good to you.